Il XV ideale della rwc 2007

Per discutere di tutto quanto riguarda la Coppa del Mondo di Francia 2007.
pecknet
Messaggi: 235
Iscritto il: 2 giu 2006, 21:45
Località: Piacenza

Il XV ideale della rwc 2007

Messaggio da pecknet » 21 ott 2007, 14:13


1 roncero
2 smit
3 castrogiovanni
4 botha
5 matfield
6 collins
7 smith
8 so'oialo
9 pichot
10 hernandez
11 habana
12 catt
13 f.contepomi
14 rokocoko
15 montgomery

16 ledesma
17 sheridan
18 albacete
19 burger
20 du preez
21 wilkinson
22 corleto
Vivas ut possit, quando nec quis ut velis

sunriseboy
Messaggi: 653
Iscritto il: 12 gen 2006, 0:00
Località: Lucca
Contatta:

RE: Il XV ideale della rwc 2007

Messaggio da sunriseboy » 21 ott 2007, 14:23

Rokocoko sì e Robinson no?....Uhm.... :?
Principio della termodinamica applicato al forum di rugby.it, altrimenti detto "legge di Flor": qualsiasi discussione dopo n pagine di thread si converte in un topic su Scanavacca.

http://www.nokappa.it

MOCKBA
Messaggi: 735
Iscritto il: 25 feb 2007, 21:36
Località: London

RE: Il XV ideale della rwc 2007

Messaggio da MOCKBA » 21 ott 2007, 14:26

Tuilagi e Rabeni in panca li metterei...impact players di un certo spessore...BOD l'unico che delle home nations (esclusa l'inghilerra) che forse dico forse terrei in riserva...
Metterei Wilko, Sheridan e Burger titolari
Nostradamus '09 XV / XV

MOCKBA
Messaggi: 735
Iscritto il: 25 feb 2007, 21:36
Località: London

Re: RE: Il XV ideale della rwc 2007

Messaggio da MOCKBA » 21 ott 2007, 14:27

sunriseboy ha scritto:Rokocoko sì e Robinson no?....Uhm.... :?
good point...Jason e' stato immenso questo mondiale, Roko non mi ha convinto molto

rask
Messaggi: 740
Iscritto il: 5 mar 2006, 0:00
Località: teramo

Re: Il XV ideale della rwc 2007

Messaggio da rask » 21 ott 2007, 14:58

La mia:

1 roncero
2 smit
3 de villiers
4 botha
5 matfield
6 dusatoir
7 smith
8 longo
9 du perez
10 wilkinson
11 habana
12 f.contepomi
13 tait
14 delasau
15 montgomery

16 ledesma
17 sheridan
18 chabal
19 fernandez lobbe
20 pichot
21 hernandez
22 corleto

unmetrodallametaèmeta
Messaggi: 237
Iscritto il: 9 mar 2007, 14:39
Località: Dietro un pilone e a fianco di una 2a linea

RE: Re: Il XV ideale della rwc 2007

Messaggio da unmetrodallametaèmeta » 21 ott 2007, 15:13

Shaw è stato immenso contro Australia e Francia e ha combattuto fino in fondo in finale. Lui e Matfield in seconda.
Bravo Rask per aver citato De Villiers, che ha messo in grossa difficoltà Sheridan e che è stato uno fra i francesi (cmq equiparato...) più positivi. Qualcuno si ricordi anche di S. Mortlock e di Agulla fra i 3/4. J. Robinson da citare assolutamente.

astronaut84
Messaggi: 1849
Iscritto il: 13 giu 2006, 2:37
Località: Napoli, Regno delle Due Sicilie
Contatta:

...

Messaggio da astronaut84 » 21 ott 2007, 17:40

Pareri discordanti su Castro...l'ho visto di là inserito nella Top of the Flops... :?
Ma è questione di punti di vista :P
Immagine

Borghese
Messaggi: 210
Iscritto il: 28 nov 2006, 21:45

RE: ...

Messaggio da Borghese » 21 ott 2007, 18:11

Roncero
Smit
Sheridan (fuori ruolo)
Matfield
Shaw
Burger
Smith
Longo
Du Preez
Hernandez
Habana
F. Contepomi
Rabeni
Aguilla
Robinson

De Villers
Ledesma
Botha
Bonnaire
Rauluni
Wilkinson
Catt
Corleto

MOCKBA
Messaggi: 735
Iscritto il: 25 feb 2007, 21:36
Località: London

RE: ...

Messaggio da MOCKBA » 21 ott 2007, 20:35

i cervelloni di planet-rugby hanno espresso il loro parere...

15 Percy Montgomery - Difficult at full-back, for Jason Robinson's chances were equal at least before he departed to injury, and Ignacio Corleto put himself in the frame with a terrific performance in Argentina's second win over France. But when it came to the crunch, under a barrage of high balls and with pressure goal and touch-kicking at its most intense, Montgomery stepped up to the mark and passed the test every time.

14 Vincent Clerc - Faded a little towards the end of the tournament, but that had far more to do with the French tactics than his own effort. Clerc weighed in with so many line and tackle breaks, belying his size, and his twinkle-toed running was a joy to watch at times. The second try he scored against Ireland showed his strength on the ball.

13 Stirling Mortlock - The only player from a team that did not make it past the quarter-finals, but Mortlock shouldered so much of the responsibility in Australia's team and broke the line so many times in attack. A dab boot from the tee too.

12 Felipe Contempomi - Delivered it all for Argentina: handling, running, goal-kicking, and even a little needle of the opposition. But most importantly, he shepherded Juan Hernandez through his first steps as a fully-fledged fly-half. His 19-point haul in the final game was a fitting end - although his silly yellow card was not.

11 Bryan Habana - The tournament's top try-scorer couldn't find the gaps in the final to make a new World Cup record his own, but England's close attentions to him in defence were reminiscent of South Africa's to a certain Jonah Lomu some 12 years ago - a compliment indeed. The semi-final, however, was all Habana's own...

10 Jonny Wilkinson - Possibly the first time since the last World Cup that he has been fit for more than a month, Wilkinson bailed England out supremely. By his own high standards he might not have been as good as 2003, but he was still the steering column that guided England's shaky axles time and time again over the roughest ground.

9 Fourie du Preez - when Jake White took over, Fourie du Preez was a fringe player, working hard on his game and concentrating on getting the decision-making right. Being stuck behind anyone in Jake White's loyal order is a tough task, but Du Preez's gradual accession to the Bok number nine shirt has been born of some incredible work and irresistible displays from the Bulls' half, and this tournament confirmed his position as a rival to Joost in the historical pecking order, as well as arguably the finest player in the world on current form.

8 Gonzalo Longo - Maybe hasn't got the unique gliding running skills of team-mate Juan Manuel Leguizamon or the busting strength of Finau Maka, or the handling skills of Danie Roussouw, but Longo has huge heart, a beaverish attitude to work, and an inexhaustible supply of strength and courage in his running and tackling. Time and time again he queued up to be Argentina's man of the match, and ended up a real unsung hero of the Pumas' campaign.

7 Thierry Dusautoir - A star to arrive out of the left field a bit at this World Cup, for Dusautoir has been on the fringes, at best, of Bernard Laporte's French ridiculously back row-rich French squad. Dusautoir was magnificent in France's triumph over New Zealand though, and although in defeat, proved that was no fluke in the semi-final against England.

6 Juan Smith* - Has been at the heart of so much that has been good about South Africa, including an excellent cameo role when Jake White needed the old heads to steer his team past Tonga. Tries, runs, tackles, all have been his forte at all times.

5 Victor Matfield - The king of the line-out, his title undisputed, Matfield's loss to France is a massive blow to SA rugby, but his man of the match performance in the final was a fitting end to a superb career.

4 Simon Shaw - The most controversial omission from Clive Woodward's 2003 title-winning squad, Shaw rolled back the years to recoup his form of that year and finally got the chance to show the world his class.

3 Pieter de Villiers - French he may be by allegiance, but the Stellenbosch-born prop takes his place in a front row populated by fellow South Africans. De Villiers held Andrew Sheridan into anonymity in the semi-final when all thought Sheridan was indestructible, a week after doing the same to Carl Hayman. An unsung hero of France's cause.

2 John Smit (captain) - Smit has continually been up there with nominations for Team of the Week, many times only losing by the odd vote, winning a couple of times. Matfield and Bakkies Botha make his job easy for him in the line-out, and he is the centrepiece of a superb pack, but he has gone through this tournament with barely a blot to his copybook, and with his leadership skills carrying a nation to victory. Australia had John Eales, England had Martin Johnson, and now Smit continues the tradition of legendary World Cup-winning captains.

1 Os du Randt - Props all over the world will be crying into their fry-ups this morning as Os calls time on his career. The Free State farmer has achieved icon status in the front-row community, and his display in the final - a rarity, for it was all 80 minutes - showed why. Sheridan is strong but can go missing in action, Hayman appears to be slowing down a tad, but at 35 years old, Os is the world's finest loosehead.
Nostradamus '09 XV / XV

timmyo'toole
Messaggi: 196
Iscritto il: 31 ago 2007, 17:29
Località: Treviso

RE: ...

Messaggio da timmyo'toole » 21 ott 2007, 20:41

15 Robinson
14 Desalau
13 Mortlock
12 Contepomi
11 Habana
10 Wilkinson
9 Du Preez
8 Bonnaire
7 Dusatoir
6 Smith
5 Matfield
4 Shaw
3 De Villiers
2 Ledesma
1 Roncero

16 Sheridan
17 Smit
18 Botha
19 Mc Caw
20 Pichot
21 Hernandez
22 Clerc

l'orco
Messaggi: 10
Iscritto il: 5 lug 2007, 17:41

RE: ...

Messaggio da l'orco » 21 ott 2007, 23:30

Un posto per Danie Rossouw da qualche parte lo troverei.
La presenza di Rokocoko mi sembra un po' forzata.

cke-Angel
Messaggi: 453
Iscritto il: 20 nov 2005, 0:00
Località: Bologna

RE: ...

Messaggio da cke-Angel » 21 ott 2007, 23:34

1) Roncero
2) Ledesma
3) Hayman
4) Ali Williams
5) Matfield
6) Burger
7) McCaw
8) Bonnaire
9) Pichot
10) Wilkinson
11) Habana
12) Jauzion
13) Mortlock
14) Robinson
15) Corleto

16) Sheridan
17) Smit
18) Botha
19) Collins
20) Hernandez
21) Steyn
22) Montgomery
If you want to get results you never got you have to do something you never did

amatorisupporter
Messaggi: 39
Iscritto il: 20 apr 2005, 0:00

Messaggio da amatorisupporter » 22 ott 2007, 19:52

la formazione di planet rugby mi trova quasi del tutto d'accordo.
metteri però hernandez a 10 (intelligente ed elegantissimo), roncero a pilone sinistro e, forse, roussouw terza centro.
una menzione la farei anche per corleto, ledesma, sheridan, i fijani seru rabeni e aquapusi quera, ali williams (unico AB) e bakkies botha.
giustissima la scelta di mortlock al centro, positivo in tutte le qualificazioni ed assolutamente incredibile nel quarto con l'inghilterra (in quella occasione non mi è dispiaciuto neanche giteau). e dire che qualcuno lo ha inserito tra i flop...

frarugby
Messaggi: 164
Iscritto il: 11 feb 2007, 19:57

Messaggio da frarugby » 22 ott 2007, 20:01

Robinson; Clerc, Rabeni , F Contepomi, Habana; JM Hernandez, Du Preez; Longo, Dusatoir, Burger; Matfield, Shaw; De Villiers, Ledesma, Sheridan.
BENCH: Roncero, Smit; Chabal, Bonnaire, Elissalde, Wilkinson, Corleto

rugbyfun
Messaggi: 146
Iscritto il: 28 feb 2007, 14:03

Messaggio da rugbyfun » 22 ott 2007, 20:15

Cito uno dei miei mediani preferiti: Mosese Rauluni (Fiji, capitano), mediano di mischia che si adatta perfettamente al gioco fijiano.

Bloccato

Torna a “RWC Francia 2007”